Відео

So well organized and researched!!!!

I hope this helped with engagement

Funny enough, i had a promotion for the white symbol shirt for this channel in the corner. I know its the channel symbol in white but "white symbol" missing the shirt context on a video about nationalism and grand narratives... Ok it's not that funny...

I love you cipher as we are parted on to different sides of aisle waving with friendly grace.

Thanks!!!

You are probably the only reason I survived history grad school because it took me a lot longer than I liked to understand historiography

I came to the comment section for engagement and to ask how many people would get triggered by this video that's literally defining words... And I couldn't start typing before someone was triggered and invoked Crypto.

If they are not stealing from or killing you or your family friend in a free society. We stay in our own lane. We have very few powerful people with bad intentions who seek to confuse our young minds into forgetting the simplicity of freedom and happiness with fantastic stories of injustice leaving out the beautiful unity and struggles to bring our freedoms into existence. We should respect our elders and the horrors they endured so we could live in such peace that we spend our time thinking of things like this and we are not bleeding on battlefield or burying our loved ones from starvation from poverty to keep the landlord’s power from our own prejudice god bless

why does it feel like you're becoming a commie I don't get it bro, what changed you was it the historian degree?

Good short form content 😱

It's true, Texans are arrogant

Texas is not worried about New Mexico, for sure!!! We're just states as neighbors!!!

Stay mad nationalists. Y'all's mythology is bunk. Time to get with the century or at least last century, cause you're stuck in the 19th like the neanderthals you are

Yes, nationalism is newish, but the idea of borders and boundaries between states is not new. In a way, when not missused, nationalism is an improvement on the past because it is driven by the importance of the will of the people within the state they resided.

I would totally buy a Teddy Roosevelt Social Justice Warrior t-shirt

Your avatar looks like Postal dude from Postal 2.

What’s up RGV

Thanks!

Thanks!

You are doing an exceptional job making USA-American history fascinating for this German who lives in china.

A disturbing film

Anytime Hollywood makes a historical move, I don't trust it since they have an agenda.

Thank you. This was great

Such an underrated concept! In political science as well (this is where I've been introduced to it).

Nations and their boundaries are made-up man-made ideas just like religions and gods. Hopefully we'll finally grow up some day soon and progress to the next level of a global civilization

Nation is real But nationalism isn’t

I am a little surprised that you didn’t mention how Teddy was a quintessential part in forming the NCAA and the governance of college athletics post presidency

Right wing conspiracies revolves around George soros and Jews in general immigration and homophobia left wing conspiracies usually involve the cia and the imf 😂

Angry Turk appeared

Just finished reading Imagined Communities, and I loved it for the historgraphy and great use of sources! It made me rethink how I see not only nations but also other Communities that are imagined/craft.

Crazy interesting. Thanks for the video.

No lie, I once had a middle school teacher say that cinco de mayo was Mexican Independence Day and celebrated when they kicked Napoleon out (not Napoleon III mind you, NAPOLEON NAPOLEON)

Easy to let people know who you are talking about. FEATHER OR DOT!

There were no saints in bleeding Kansas.

Hey, I know I only have 2 years of community college and a 5 year apprenticeship as a Steamfitter working in nuclear, coal, gas and oil fired power plants plus oil refineries but what the hell did that mean?

I like the cop shows when they get the bad guy.

I was born and raised in Alaska. The state is overall incredibly weird in terms of politics and cultural attitudes relative to the continental US. Even though most people here have no direct connection to the South, there is some resonance in the spirit of rebellion against the state inspired by Lost Cause mythology. I think this is a combination of both the significant libertarian slant of the politics here, and they also see a closer connection to a stereotypical lifestyle of the south given that the south has much more rural populations and smaller/less aggregates major metropolitan areas. I mean you don’t hear about country boys/girls nearly as much in reference to the northern states as you do to the south, and a large portion of people who live in AK, even those living in suburbs or small cities, consider themselves to be country folk. But anyways, education on the civil war was interesting because the textbooks we used and the general curriculum about the civil war in class did not include lost cause talking points. However, i have had multiple teachers who said things like “the civil war wasn’t about slavery” (if they clarified most would say it was about keeping the union together) or talking about just how damn honorable and righteous Robert E Lee was. Then I’d have other teachers who would say that it was about slavery, and they would make no attempts to idolize the confederacy or its military leaders. Needless to say, it was a bit confusing to go back and forth on the ideological basis of the Civil War basically every time it was covered by a new teacher. Thankfully, i was not someone who bought into the bullshit for long and was able to learn what the actual truth was (there was a phase for a bit in middle school and first couple years of highschool where i didn’t know who i wanted to be and ended up going along with politics i now find to be incredibly superficial and badly informed, the state still is a red state even with the libertarianism so lots of conservative attitudes were still prevalent). I can only imagine how difficult it would be to accept you had been misinformed if you spent your entire childhood and adolescence being taught the Lost Cause narrative.

The feeling is mutual

I'm from Arizona and had to take 2 years of Arizona history in 1975-76 and I've never heard of the Pleasant valley war until this moment. I _have_ heard the name Tuxberry... I hope I spelled that correctly...and that they fought over grazing rights or something, I'm not sure, but I think I heard that name on another old west oriented UA-cam channel, not at school. We complain about underfunded schools now and I agree, they are. Both my sister's are at least master's level special ed teachers, but not in Arizona, the pay was so low that they both had to go back to retail, for a $2.10 per hour minimum wage because they made more money. It's pretty gross, but public education in this country has always been grossly inadequate, that's why people who blame the government or private businesses for a variety of perceived wrongs don't know how their own government, or economy, works. I realize some districts and states are better than other's, but until the mid 1980's that I'm aware of, the humanities are almost entirely useless not because they're not needed, but because the curriculum is so utterly inadequate and filled with the so called "patriotic education" that Republicans are calling for now.

I can't let this go, and yes, I do have background in this particular subject. One reason, perhaps the major reason for the _name_ "national socialist" is because socialism was becoming very popular with destitute German workers and the monied elites, they never like that. So the party was christened "the national socialist German workers party" to sway votes towards the Nazi's. Just sayin'.

OMG I can't stop laughing at Tigerstar's responses.

LOVE ALBUQUERQUE. BEST CITY IN AMERICA!

This was a very informative video! As an undergraduate student, I read “They Can Live in the Desert but Nowhere Else” by Ronald Suny, which is an excellent must-read on the Armenian Genocide. It’s interesting that you mention the role of Armenian nationalism as almost being one of the causes of the Genocide, because Suny largely dismisses this. He argues that above all else, the Young Turks were empire preservers, desperate to hold on to their power/empire in a rapidly changing world of nation states. In the context of the First World War, they came to believe that the Armenians were a threat, despite the fact that Armenian desertion rates in the Ottoman Army were very low and despite the fact that Armenians were always considered a “loyal millet” of the empire. Events like the Battle of Sarikamish during WWI (which you alluded to) were enough evidence for the Young Turks to conjure up an image of Armenian disloyalty, and for them to convince themselves that to preserve the empire, Armenians had to be systematically eradicated. In the historiography of the Genocide, it certainly butts heads with some of the conventional thinking.

Hollywood making NASA look racist when it is actually at the forefront of the Civil Rights Movement. Just shows how false propaganda can change opinions. Hollywood should do a racist movie about themselves (like that's going to happen). 😂

It's the dude going up the ladder, then not allowing the ones behind him to come up.

You glide right past Estavan, who is a fascinating character in his own right. Gabriel Garcia Marquez takes him as his avatar in his story of "The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World.

There aren't enough moral panics about moral panics. For that reason, I bought a shirt and became a Patron.

I used to support the Black Panthers and Communism. Now' I'm a political Centrist/Moderate, Best thing I've ever done, Blessed Be.

I grew up in a tourist town l detest tourists.ln my experience, New Mexicans hate Texas tourists.